Industry: Financial services, credit union contact center
Challenge: Manual QA had reached the limit of what six senior staff could review by hand
Result: Coverage expanded from four calls per agent per month to effectively every call, with $32,718 in confirmed annualized labor savings and six consecutive months of rising quality scores
Company Overview
The client is a regional credit union operating a contact center of 50 to 60 agents, handling inbound and outbound calls across servicing, lending, and member support. Quality assurance sat with a small group of senior staff who reviewed calls manually as part of a broader set of coaching, escalation, and compliance responsibilities. Leadership’s objective was to expand QA coverage and improve coaching consistency without adding headcount to a team already operating at capacity. This engagement used speech and interaction analytics to automate call center QA, bringing effectively every call at the credit union into scoring.
The Challenge
Before the engagement, the credit union’s QA program reviewed approximately four calls per agent per month, a rate of roughly 48 calls per representative per year. Each reviewed call took more than 30 minutes of senior staff time for playback, documentation, scoring, feedback, and coaching follow-up. Three Senior Representatives, two Assistant Managers, and one Manager were running that process alongside their other responsibilities. They were not performing poorly. They had reached the ceiling of what a manual process can produce at contact center volume, and expanding coverage under the existing model meant hiring more senior staff, since the math of 30 minutes per call does not scale through effort alone.
Why the Existing Approach Failed
Sampling at four calls a month left the vast majority of agent-member interactions completely unreviewed, which meant compliance risks, coaching opportunities, and behavioral patterns across most of the call volume stayed invisible by default. At four calls a month, a supervisor has a 90 percent chance of detecting a behavior only if it shows up on 44 percent or more of an agent’s calls. The capacity constraint created a second, less obvious problem. Manual QA scoring is inherently susceptible to reviewer variance, since even well-trained staff naturally interpret the same behavioral criteria with some degree of subjectivity. At four calls a month, that variance is difficult to detect or correct, which means part of what a manual score reflects is the reviewer, not just the agent being reviewed. A sampled process built on inconsistent inputs cannot produce a reliable population-level picture of agent quality, no matter how experienced the reviewers are.
The Zenylitics Approach
Data Layer. Every inbound and outbound call across the contact center, captured and processed through the CallMiner conversation analytics platform.
Analytics Layer. Automated scorecards applying consistent scoring logic across the full monitored call population, starting with a core QA card and expanding over a structured 90-day sequence to additional scorecards covering key points, upsell behavior, soft skills, process adherence, and compliance criteria.
Human Intelligence Layer. An embedded Zenylitics analyst team operated the platform end to end, rather than handing the credit union a software license and a training session. That team handled scorecard configuration, category tuning, automated scoring validation, and calibration cycles, then packaged the findings into guided insights supervisors could take directly into coaching conversations.
Action Layer. Supervisors stopped transcribing individual calls and started coaching from documented, population-level patterns, with the same six senior staff who ran the original manual program now working from complete coverage instead of a narrow sample. Weekly working sessions moved to a biweekly cadence once the program stabilized.
Key Insights Discovered
Full coverage did not just widen the sample. It surfaced behaviors a four-call-per-month review could never have reliably detected in the first place.
Recap language was consistently low-scoring across the agent population, with agents closing interactions without clearly summarizing resolution or confirming next steps with members, a pattern that had never surfaced reliably in the old manual sample. Investigative language gaps, meaning whether agents asked sufficient probing questions to properly diagnose a member’s issue, only became measurable once hundreds of interactions were being scored against the same consistent criteria. Call avoidance and silence signals, including late call openings, extended silence, and long holds, moved from occasional anecdotal observations to documented, coachable patterns. Upsell behavior became measurable across the full agent population for the first time, through a scorecard that did not exist before the engagement.
Coaching itself changed in character. An agent with consistently low scores on investigative language across 30 monitored calls now receives a fundamentally different, more targeted coaching conversation than one built from a single call chosen at random, since the supervisor is coaching against a real pattern rather than a single data point.
The expanded coverage also produced a compliance benefit beyond QA scoring. The credit union used documentation from the program during review of a hearing-impaired member’s service issue, supporting a contingency plan with a call record that extended well beyond the handful of calls a sampled process would have captured that month.
Business Outcomes
Coverage expanded from four calls per agent per month to automated scoring covering effectively every call across the monitored population, over the July to December 2025 measurement period.
The credit union calculated $32,718 in confirmed annualized labor savings under its current sampled QA policy. Manually reviewing the same call population now covered through automated scoring would require a projected $6,434,072 a year in internal labor. This second number is not a realized savings amount. The figure represents the value of the engagement and shows how unrealistic it is to expect manual call review to find every issue.
The credit union now has six consecutive months of data showing quality improved. Between September 2025 and February 2026, verification and disclosure compliance scores rose 5.2 percent, the core QA scorecard improved in every single month of that window, and etiquette scores climbed as well. The starting scores in this period came in lower than the credit union’s prior manual averages, which reflects a change in measurement accuracy rather than a decline in agent performance. At four calls a month, reviewer inconsistency could not be detected, so the earlier manual average ran more generously than the underlying behavior actually supported. Once every call was scored against the same criteria, the population-level average reset to a more accurate baseline before climbing from there.
Why This Matters
The credit union faced a choice about widening QA coverage, and the manual route meant hiring dozens more people. This credit union’s QA team did not need more senior staff to see everything. They needed a way to apply the judgment those six people already had across every call instead of four a month, and to trust that the resulting scores reflected agent behavior rather than which reviewer happened to be listening that day.
FAQs
How many calls does automated QA cover at a credit union contact center?
Automated QA at this credit union effectively covers every call across the monitored population, where manual review covered approximately four calls per agent per month. The program applies consistent scoring logic to the full call population and expands over a structured 90-day sequence to additional scorecards.
Does automated QA support credit union compliance?
Automated QA supports credit union compliance by scoring compliance criteria on every call. At this credit union, verification and disclosure compliance scores rose 5.2 percent between September 2025 and February 2026, and documentation from the program supported the review of a hearing-impaired member’s service issue.
How much labor does automated QA save a credit union?
The credit union calculated $32,718 in confirmed annualized labor savings under its current sampled QA policy. Manually reviewing the same call population would require a projected $6,434,072 a year in internal labor.
Schedule a Zenylitics demo to see how automated QA can cover every call in your credit union contact center.